So I've recently decided to theme one of my characters on the Alliance (Stormwind in particular).
I have all of my armor, and 2 2-handed swords already done. What I need to find, however, are both a 2-handed mace and axe, just in case they are the weapons I end up with. I thought about using the original PVP stuff at first, but then remembered that I couldn't without the Feat of Strength. So I'm open to any suggestions.
Weapons from Trial of the Crusader. Pretty cool 2H axe from there. There was a nice 2H mace that was gold/blue, but you can only get it from like the first quest in MOP now, which means you've probably vendored it.
For a mace, I like Hammer of Grief (http://www.wowhead.com/item=38618), or Hammer of the Naaru, since Dranei count as Alliance (http://www.wowhead.com/item=28800). Other than those, for Mace, less is more. The Commanding Mallet is almost exactly the same model as the old level 20 Alliance Pally quest weapon, Verigan's Fist, and all the maces that share that model are pretty "Alliance"-ish. Ditto the Heart Fire Warhammer and shared models.
For an axe, again, less is more -- if you mean Alliance themed as in "standard issue, military looking", go on MogIt and hunt through vanilla greens. Otherwise, just apply the Rule of Cool on anything that isn't explicitly Horde-styled. I'm very fond of Stormedge from Uld 10, or the Burning Crusader from a Netherstorm quest.