I didn't have the achievements for DS heroic but I am a raider, I quit after the first week of DS cause it was crap.Well.. I wouldn't call anyone who don't have the ds hc achievements a raider.
Seems to be a common issue. First we were on Spirit Kings HC, we wiped for 60-90 minutes. Had the last boss down to 40% after like 8-10 pulls. Yet people were all like "omg lets skip this". Really, I am used to spending weeks progressing, wiping to a boss for hours and hours. People nowadays seems to expect a boss to die after 30 mintues or its unkillable. "We lack the gear", no you don't lack the gear, your just terrible.
No matter what path you walk in life we all have to face Jaraxxus one day.
Raiders give up so easily because of LFR. Why do all this crap to down normal and heroic stuff when I can have a fun non stress inducing run, and down everything in 1-2 attempts and get pretty much the same gear. All in less time. Some people play for fun, some want to make it their life. There are a lot less of the latter.
All I have gathered from this thread is that a raider can be someone who makes a livelihood gunning for world firsts, OR somebody who tries to pug year old content.
If you look at it that way, it's pretty easy to understand why "Raiders give up so easily" - it's because you're talking about the raiders who give up easily.
inb4 "Why do raiders NEVER give up?" thread pops up
And why does Professor Oak sound like Tristan Taylor from Yu Gi Oh the abridged series now? But on topic, never had too much trouble with the whole giving up scenario, then again I only raided in BC and WOTLK, played Cata for bout a month and leveled my derp knight to 90 then got bored. For a breakdown in my wrath days: it was quite impossible to fail in naxx, so no issues there. Ulduar was different, due to sheer length most pug groups I was with ended up stopping during the antechamber, maybe two bosses in, normally hodir for a chance at some rare cache loot and Thorim cause it was easy (never did iron council with a pug), had some failures there but since most people liked the raid, again at least for me, most people stuck around. For me it started getting bad around ToC. Basically if the group failed at the worms, chances the raid breaks up right then and there. Failure at the yeti was normally ok, and the group stuck around. Second boss is a pushover, which is good because when we reached the champs I knew we were finishing, good morale boost that second boss. ICC, again it wasn't that people qq dropped, it was that people didn't want to deal with putricide or sindragosa. First four in like 45 minutes, then festergut and rotface, then the blood jersey shore douches, and finally venereal disease. If the group stuck it out that far then maybe we would try the blood bitch.
TL;DR, why does professor oak sound like tristian from YGOTAS and for me it was more about length then quitting.
P.S. You didn't pug BC raids cept Kara, for me again.
To answer the question in the title:
For the majority of players, since WotLK. That was the beginning of the "let's just wait until its nerfed" mentality.
Caveat: actually, we saw a little glimmer when people gave up on Sunwell when they announced they would have raid-wide nerfs because people were crying about M'uru being too hard. Folks that struggled through BT/Hyjal stood no chance in SWP, so instead of wiping night after night, they just sat back and waited because of the early nerf announcement.
"There are two types of guys in this world. Guys who sniff their fingers after scratching their balls, and dirty fucking liars." -StylesClashv3
"Elo Hell is where the Ego is greater than the Elo." -Bystekhilcar
A raid is 10 - 40 people working together. I am yet to see that happen in LFR...
In LFR "every man for himself" rings a familiar bell.
IF its a raid, you are raiding, so you are a raider. . .
What kind of raider , thats the difference.
since Wotlk spoiled them
A group with for example iLvl 380 progressing in BoT in Cata would have also been classified as a raid group and as raiders.
No, just clearing LFR doesn't make you a raider. That's complete nonsense and you will understand this if you've ever been in a raid group for more than one evening. There is minimal effort, no progression and nearly no teamwork / coordination in a LFR group.
Obviously my opinion doesn't mean anything to anyone but myself but I'll put my two cents in. I can write enough lines of code to make something that spits out my name when I input the letter 'Q'. Guess I should go add programmer to my resume. In my opinion, classifying yourself as a raider requires a certain level of effort. Destroying a lvl 60 raid with 5 of your friends doesn't really count as raiding, yes you are in a raid group, yes the instance you are in was considered a raid but you aren't playing the content as it was intended. You aren't raiding you're facerolling... Some people consider doing LFR makes them a raider but I would never consider myself a raider for going in and half assing my way through it. If I had to arbitrarily set a line it would be doing at least LFR for the expansion you are in, so doing any raid that is designed for the current level cap. Like I said I wouldn't personally consider myself a raider for doing it but I see it as a fair enough spot to draw a line.
Last edited by Najja; 2012-12-10 at 03:00 PM.
Seriously? People really consider themselves raiders while the only thing they do is LFR? Oh my god, I always thought those people wouldn't exist...
Currently, I'm NOT a raider. My old guild fell apart (cleared 8/8 DS hc at ~15%ish nerf with 2 raid nights a week, we started late with progression and whatnot but just so you know at what level of raider you could put me^^) and I joined a new one with the start of MoP only to realize that it's full of douches/noobs and left after the first few raids. Atm, the only thing I do, from a PvE perspective, is LFR and the occasional daily quest. This makes me a NON-raiding individual, period. LFR can't be and will never be (unless they change the very essence of it) considered raiding by any half-serious player.