Originally Posted by
Nairobi
Touching on this a bit more, and taking from other games (like LOL), I would say that higher rankings should also contribute something to the person being ranked (either positively or negatively). So, say you are a LFD/LFR all-star, who does their job well and isn't a total douche, and frequently get scored at 4-5, you get something like 5-10 bonus VP per run (10-20 in LFR). If you score high enough, maybe even get to earn a satchel (like tanks/healers do sometimes)...would be nice for DPS to have a chance at this.
I would say that scoring low should have a negative effect, but honestly that would just facilitate trolls/assholes from ranking everyone at 1, to be a dick. I guess you could artificially rank people high as well, but you could disable voting for members of the same guild, to prevent "rating trading" in guild groups.
I like this idea, and think that maybe it could even return some sense of community and foster some "helpful advice" from folks rather than just "LOLNUB, VTK".