This question comes from me not understanding why people would be opposed to such a change.
Why should Blizzard NOT give higher item level loot in 25 player raids?
I mean, if they justified the higher item level loot by increasing the difficulty slightly in 25, and also with the logistical problems involved in creating 25 player guilds, why would this be a bad thing?
Lets create an example to help me illustrate my point:
If 10 man raiding is kept a challenge, and several guilds like the 10 man style, why would it matter if better gear is in 25 man, especially if it is a little more difficult to obtain? You would still progress through the raiding environment with your guild on your own schedule. You would eventually get to 10 man heroic raiding, and once you beat all the encounters in 10 man heroic raiding, you are done. Your guild is the most progressed in the game. You have essentially completed the game completely. (i currently raid in a 10 player environment very casually, as I am not hardcore anymore like i used to be)
So i ask again, why NOT give higher ilvl loot to 25 player raids?
Caution: Please do not make this into a 10 vs 25 man debate because it could be locked if you do so.