Relic of xuen VS Woundripper Medallion

[Deleted]

Hello hunter community i was trying today to check which trinket is better this morning on femaledwarf but unfortunately the trinket from Warson offensive is not listed in the database so i would like to ask which 1 is better.I would appreciate an answer or a site that could help me to figure it out!

[Viradiance]

Why not use both?

[Deleted]

Seeing how xuen is tied BiS with Terror in the Mists HC, I would quite comfortable assume that the Woundripper Medallion isn't even close.

[Knightsavior]

You can also try AskMrRobot.com, but Xuen is much better than the Woundripper Medallion, anything that procs Agility tends to be better than something that is on use for crit.

[Deleted]

At the moment im Using Bottle 489 along with relic!Thanks a lot for the feedback i appreciate it!

[Norjak]

Woundripper might be good for BM since the on-use is on the same cd timer as BW. Also the Agi is baseline (not a proc) so it would be more consistent in this regard. Maybe a good replacement for bottle, however as already pointed out the relic is close to BiS all the way up to heroic drops.

[Shonvel]

How about Woundripper Medallion vs Bottle (LFR) ?

[Tehstool]

Woundripper might be good for BM since the on-use is on the same cd timer as BW. Also the Agi is baseline (not a proc) so it would be more consistent in this regard. Maybe a good replacement for bottle, however as already pointed out the relic is close to BiS all the way up to heroic drops.

The woundripper medallion is pretty close to the bottle. I'd say keep the bottle and upgrade something else with the 1750 vp you saved.

The bottle gives 3236 * 20 / 45 : 1438.22222222 agi averaged out and the woundripper medallion gives 959.5 crit averaged out

So its comes down to

Bottle
1438.2 proc agi
431 crit
648 mastery


Medallion
1152 static agility
959.5 proc crit

136.2312 crit gain from the bottle's agility

The bottle has
286.2 more agility
392.2688 less crit
648 more mastery

The bottle looks pretty good to me. I'd stick with it and use your vp to upgrade something else.

How about Woundripper Medallion vs Bottle (LFR) ?

The LFR bottle barely gives more agi than the medallion and less stats. I'd go with the medallion if there isn't anything else to spend your vp on.

[Konik]

Medallion is simming better than LFR Bottle for me on FD (~300dps)

//edit

not sure about Medallion vs Terror (LFR) tho

[Deleted]

The woundripper medallion is pretty close to the bottle. I'd say keep the bottle and upgrade something else with the 1750 vp you saved.

The bottle gives 3236 * 20 / 45 : 1438.22222222 agi averaged out and the woundripper medallion gives 959.5 crit averaged out

So its comes down to

Bottle
1438.2 proc agi
431 crit
648 mastery


Medallion
1152 static agility
959.5 proc crit

136.2312 crit gain from the bottle's agility

The bottle has
286.2 more agility
392.2688 less crit
648 more mastery

The bottle looks pretty good to me. I'd stick with it and use your vp to upgrade something else.




The LFR bottle barely gives more agi than the medallion and less stats. I'd go with the medallion if there isn't anything else to spend your vp on.

Thanks a lot for the constructive feedback i truly appreciate it!

[Tehterokkar]

Medallion lines up with BW, but if you have Engineering, that sort of ruins it..

[S7orm]

one simple rule in this game: if the trinket is similar to DMC:Greatness, it's going to be BiS for 2 tiers

[Woobels]

one simple rule in this game: if the trinket is similar to DMC:Greatness, it's going to be BiS for 2 tiers

And hey, that rule is broken because it doesn't even have to be BiS for this tier depending on your preference between Terror and DMC.