Batman: Arkham Mafia

[BrandonC]

Fair, enough, though I had assumed that he had stopped the PMing post last day.

[listo95]

If you are implying he got the information from me you are wrong, only person I have ever did a PM to was Greeney, and that is with actions and answer to riddles.

[BrandonC]

The way I got faraway may not mean they are scum/mad hatter. For all we know he is telling the truth about having a power role. But with tracking I can never get the full answer unless I track a person who killed a person on the same night. But I just wonder why everyone is saying only worgen and lysah would be targets if faraway come back town,only real reason is the voting with no reason (that I can think of). At least for me I had information to go with my vote.

I'm just saying that the combination is fairly weighty evidence in a game that is, thus far, lacking in many solid leads.

[Firebert]

If you are implying he got the information from me you are wrong, only person I have ever did a PM to was Greeney, and that is with actions and answer to riddles.

I'm sorry, I didn't mean to put what I said in such a way that you'd make that inference.

What I am saying is that Worgenite got the information either from his own Town Power Role, or was informed of it during the night, hence the insta-vote this Morning. I'm also saying that either Worgenite shared this information with Lysah, or Lysah got it from the same source that Worgenite got it. Without role-claims from either party (I'd strongly prefer Worgenite), all this is is a repeat of Yesterday and Day 1, where we all blindly follow Worgenite's lynch target.

Note that both Arlee and NightFury Treann were Town Aligned.

[Loaf]

Note that both Arlee and NightFury Treann were Town Aligned.

Note that I didn't not have a vote for either person either. I believed both Treann(though I did continue to push a lynch) and Arlee after their claim/explanation.

[BrandonC]

Except for the addition of listo's unconnected concerns about Faraway.

edit: this was in response to Firebert.

[Rollo]

I believe Faraway is at 8 and Worgenite is at 7. And I apologize Greeney, I miss read Kapayas unvote as an "unvote vote" >.<

And Firebert, if you're intention is to keep the vote at L-3 for either person, if suggest switching off to no one at the moment, although I don't think we will get any further with Worgenite or Lysah.

[Firebert]

Note that I didn't not have a vote for either person either. I believed both Treann(though I did continue to push a lynch) and Arlee after their claim/explanation.

It's very easy to push a bandwagon and then get off before they get lynched.

Do you have an explanation for obtaining information about Faraway?

[listo95]

I'm just curious at this point as to why Nuex came and voted, but never decided to give a small reason.

[Firebert]

And Firebert, if you're intention is to keep the vote at L-3 for either person, if suggest switching off to no one at the moment, although I don't think we will get any further with Worgenite or Lysah.

My patience is running thin with Worgenite.

UNVOTE.

---------- Post added 2013-01-29 at 12:59 AM ----------

I'm just curious at this point as to why Nuex came and voted, but never decided to give a small reason.

Bandwagoning is also very easy.

[Decagon]

Why did Lysah say you had detective abilities then?

[Firebert]

Why did Lysah say you had detective abilities then?

Who, and source?

[listo95]

Who, and source?

A town should not be okay losing a detective for one scum when there is an entire team of them.

Here it is.

[Decagon]

Note that I didn't not have a vote for either person either. I believed both Treann(though I did continue to push a lynch) and Arlee after their claim/explanation.

You and Lysah were the ones that were most adamant in lynching Treann. You were the reason I was convinced into voting on Treann (and the fact that he gave up), even though I tried hard to convince others not to lynch him. After being called bad at the game and worse than everyone else in the game, I followed everyone else's logic and we ended up lynching a cop. Again, YOU were the ONLY reason I voted on Arlee. So far, you've pushed lynched on no one but town, and while I'm willing to make an exception with Arlee because of the circumstance, you and Lysah are the main reason Treann was killed Day 1. Don't try to say that you didn't get them killed.

---------- Post added 2013-01-28 at 06:12 PM ----------

Who, and source?

What listo said (it was directed at those voting on Worge). Lysah essentially claimed Worge had a detective abilities and Worge said he was town. I feel as though we've caught them in a lie with this.

[Rigimi44]

What the heck, I will go with my gut instinct. I think Faraway is the Mad Hatter, so I will throw my vote on him.

Vote Faraway

[Greeney]

The Dwarf Lover, your previous vote was already on Faraway.

Faraway: 7 / 10
Worgenite: 7 / 10
Dyra: 1 / 10
Kapaya: 1 / 10

1. Lysah - Vote: Faraway14 #1397
2. Worgenite - Vote: Faraway14 #1358
3. Dyra - Vote: Faraway14 #1434
4. Kapaya V2 - No Vote #1485
5. BrandonC - Vote Faraway14 #1575
6. Anakso - Vote: Worgenite #1363
7. listo95 - Vote: Faraway14 #1361
8. Mumbles85 - Vote: Faraway14 #1537
9. Allysene
10. rolo4804 - Vote: Worgenite #1539
11. The Dwarf Lover - Vote: Faraway14 #1595
12. Firebert - Vote: No Vote #1590
13. Decagon - Vote: Worgenite #1551
14. Kuthe - Vote: Worgenite #1419
15. Vanatos - Vote: Kapaya #1569
16. Celtic209 - Vote: Worgenite #1490
17. Faraway14 - Vote: Worgenite #1558
18. Falbacca - Vote: Dyra #1411
19. Nuex - Vote: Worgenite #1577

[Firebert]

Here it is.

I believe she was implying that either herself, Worgenite, or a player revealed during Worgenite's role claim is the detective.

[Decagon]

I believe she was implying that either herself, Worgenite, or a player revealed during Worgenite's role claim is the detective.

So they're furthering the chance of being NKed but still not given us info, eh?

[Firebert]

So they're furthering the chance of being NKed but still not given us info, eh?

Yes.

They want more investigation days when that's clearly not going to be possible.

[Lysah]

Maybe we're both bombs and trying to get NKed and you're bloody ruining it as hard as you can scumbert.