Saint's replacement was Celtic209.
ao we really can't be safe to tell which characters are in a mafia and which ones are not.
In my opinion the ones I'm fairly sure of is that The mad hatter and the rider are not "scum." The mad hatter has not killed ot my knowledge and the riddler works off the riddles. makes no sense for him to be aligned
Why do you believe the Mad Hatter to not be scum? He could be aligned with another person, another group (Funhouse or Assassins), or he could just not have a killing role at all (unless, like pointed out by Dyra and a few others, his killing role is narrow and dependent on stuff).
---------- Post added 2013-02-02 at 02:08 PM ----------
Oh and he typo'd the riddler as the rider.
---------- Post added 2013-02-02 at 02:15 PM ----------
Is anyone else suspicious of listo as our other tracker was town? We've had 2 jailkeepers (one town one mafia) and I would assume that works with the rest of the roles as well. listo may very well be a tracker, but a mafia one. He targeted assassins mafia night 2 and 3, so if he were part of their scum team, those would be wasted. If he was funhouse, he would have known Faraway wasn't Mad Hatter and wouldn't have pushed so hard for his lynch. Scratch that idea, just something I was thinking.
I dunno, I think listo took a big chance to come out and say he was tracker, I'd like to think he's town, but we can't really confirm him as town anymore than we can anyone else.
Also, how could the Riddler not be scum? The Riddler in the story (I haven't been reading it all, tbh) seems pretty malicious and seems to be at least trying to kill people. I don't think he's aligned with anyone, but I still think he's scum.
sorry, I really should watch what I post!
Anyways if the riddler kills each night based on the riddle he couldn't possibly win if he should just stay alive. that's why I think he's something like Harvey dent, a survivor.
we should lynch dya, falbacca, or mumble is my opinion.
I'm confused as to why Dyra and Fal are under the scope?
I want to know what the hatter does. Honestly would surprise me if he turns out being the doc or backup.
Also, i was thinking what's the chance of traitors? Like in regular games. Could explain one or two missing kills.
Mind my lack of posting. Farewells. So been intoxicated.
Also spelling or lack of sense can be blamed on my new phone. At work currently
---------- Post added 2013-02-03 at 11:56 AM ----------
Also. Where be art thou worgz?
We stopped searching for monsters under our beds when we realized that they were inside us.
Tell me something, my friend. You ever dance with the devil in the pale moonlight?
I didn't think of that Aethon, but just because he can do something with Riddles doesn't mean that he's entirely limited to riddles as well.
Dyra and Fal are under the scope because of Fal's post about Dyra last game (and vote on Dyra) and Dyra's targeting of Fal this night (assuming we believe listo).
I'm wondering where Worge is as well, he hasn't posted once, and it's a few days in already.
I have to agree that the Riddler can only kill someone if they got the answer wrong. But I do see that I got a little suspicion, but I am town and if I could prove it any other way I would.
@Mod: vote count and time remaining please?
I need to do some scum hunting. Superbowl tomorrow though.