Batman: Arkham Mafia

[Lysah]

I just hope, after Worgenite and I die today and tonight, you kids take a serious look at Faraway and realize maybe we really were on to something. Enjoy your little mafia game, I really have nothing more to say.

@Firebert
You'll have to kill me to find out mine, I believe role claiming is bad form unless part of a design to find scum. It does nothing to prove you're town other than give the scum more information (since they know who scum is already). I'm not going to give the scum a solid reason to NK or not NK me before night even begins.

[Firebert]

Current vote tally

Faraway's voteswitched to Worgenite, so Worgenite is now at L-2.

---------- Post added 2013-01-28 at 10:47 PM ----------

I just hope, after Worgenite and I die today and tonight, you kids take a serious look at Faraway and realize maybe we really were on to something. Enjoy your little mafia game, I really have nothing more to say.

I've got a far better plan than that:

UNVOTE.
VOTE: Faraway14.

Worgenite's at L-3. I'm willing to hammer if Worgenite refuses to role-claim.

[Rollo]

Not voting faraway is fine, but to counter vote the guy making the claim is unreasonable.

And you sound willing to lose the game just to prove a point to Worgenite. Pretty solid town play.

Doom and gloom. It's always doom and gloom with you Lysah. It may be unreasonable, but we've given you and Worgenite a reasonable amount of time to help us out. Simply saying "I CAN'T TELL YOU YOU JUST GOTTA TRUST ME!!!" isn't getting people on your side. There really have been no other targets to go for today unfortunately. Well, there was, but YOU completely ignored MY push on Allysene. Up until a few posts ago that was where my vote was placed. I'd rather see Allysene lynched than anyone else this round, but only 2 others had a vote on him. Unfortunately, voting Allysene wouldn't give us the record voting Worgenite would, or Faraway. But as I said, this Faraway's logic > your own, and this is a game of logic and reason.

[Lysah]

Enjoy lynching townies, goodbye.

[Deleted]

I'm willing to hammer if Worgenite refuses to role-claim.

how is that different from what he's (not) doing now?

[Rollo]

Faraway's voteswitched to Worgenite, so Worgenite is now at L-2.

---------- Post added 2013-01-28 at 10:47 PM ----------


I've got a far better plan than that:

UNVOTE.
VOTE: Faraway14.

Worgenite's at L-3. I'm willing to hammer if Worgenite refuses to role-claim.

Yeah I caught Faraway's switch as I posted, yours won't be in the update though. My tally is up to date with my post number, but yes, Worgenite is L-3.

---------- Post added 2013-01-28 at 02:53 PM ----------

Enjoy lynching townies, goodbye.

You make it so enjoyable =)

This game that is.

[Firebert]

how is that different from what he's (not) doing now?

Because the pressure to roleclaim increases with more votes on the player, and I'm not willing to lynch Worgenite right now.

[Rigimi44]

Worgenite is close, I am wondering if I should consider mercy voting soon. I will stay on Faraway for now, but if Worgen gets another vote I will throw my vote on him to just end this.

[Vanatos]

Listo took a big risk in revealing what he knows so I tend to believe he had found something with Faraway. I question is whether he is Timothy Drake (Robin) or not or whether he did a night action involving Kapaya or not. Kapaya could be someone he picked out of a hat or a fellow scum buddy. The town would not want to lose a Robin if we are wrong with the person who got voted out and Kapaya's response has been kind of suspicious. So....

Vote: Kapaya

[Kuthe]

Who is Neux? I saw his name in the vote tally and don't recall seeing him post. Is he the guy who took over?

Eh all the lurkers/afkers are the ones who haven't voted. Joy.
Day end plox, I want these two to stop being such meglomaniacs and actually cooperate with the town.

[Firebert]

Day end plox, I want these two to stop being such meglomaniacs and actually cooperate with the town.

They can co-operate with the Town if Worgenite role-claims, so I don't mind either way.

[Greeney]

rolo, I appreciate the post count. Only difference I had at the time of your post is that Kapaya's post (#1485) actually being an unvote.

Faraway: 7 / 10
Worgenite: 6 / 10
Dyra: 1 / 10
Kapaya: 1 / 10

1. Lysah - Vote: Faraway14 #1397
2. Worgenite - Vote: Faraway14 #1358
3. Dyra - Vote: Faraway14 #1434
4. Kapaya V2 - No Vote #1485
5. BrandonC
6. Anakso - Vote: Worgenite #1363
7. listo95 - Vote: Faraway14 #1361
8. Mumbles85 - Vote: Faraway14 #1537
9. Allysene
10. rolo4804 - Vote: Worgenite #1539
11. The Dwarf Lover - Vote: Faraway14 #1507
12. Firebert - Vote: Faraway14 #1562
13. Decagon - Vote: Worgenite #1551
14. Kuthe - Vote: Worgenite #1419
15. Vanatos - Vote: Kapaya #1569
16. Celtic209 - Vote: Worgenite #1490
17. Faraway14 - Vote: Worgenite #1558
18. Falbacca - Vote: Dyra #1411
19. Nuex

[Loaf]

Then either Worgenite or yourself needs to come up with another scum player, and pronto.

Oh, wait, that scum player will have no reasoning either.

---------- Post added 2013-01-28 at 10:20 PM ----------


You should blame Worgenite for making it incredibly obvious that he has a searching role, for the Town to pick up on it, and hence for Worgenite to lose his chance at trying to hit two Scum with his role.

Except I don't have a searching role lol. I'm just a vt who would rather be nk'd for being believed to have a searching role than be lynched, wasting another one of our precious lynches.

---------- Post added 2013-01-28 at 06:15 PM ----------

Faraway's voteswitched to Worgenite, so Worgenite is now at L-2.

---------- Post added 2013-01-28 at 10:47 PM ----------


I've got a far better plan than that:

UNVOTE.
VOTE: Faraway14.

Worgenite's at L-3. I'm willing to hammer if Worgenite refuses to role-claim.

I've already role claimed.

I am a vt

kthxbai

[Firebert]

I've already role claimed.
I am a vt
kthxbai

Then how did you come by your information that Faraway is guaranteed scum?

[BrandonC]

vote faraway

if he isn't scum, there are two targets for next day.

[Firebert]

You'll have to kill me to find out mine, I believe role claiming is bad form unless part of a design to find scum.

That's fine. It's common knowledge now that Worgenite's alignment is linked with yours.

It does nothing to prove you're town other than give the scum more information (since they know who scum is already).

Unless there's more than one scum faction, and, roleclaiming and making yourself a target has no personal benefit, but makes it blindingly clear that you're telling the truth. Worgenite claiming VT just makes his position look worse.

I'm not going to give the scum a solid reason to NK or not NK me before night even begins.

They don't need one: this is why we're here in the first place. Voting without reason.

[TenebrusDH]

Vote: Worgenite

[BrandonC]

I think that the fact that two players seem to have come up with faraway independent of each other should count for something here, shouldn't it?

[Firebert]

I think that the fact that two players seem to have come up with faraway independent of each other should count for something here, shouldn't it?

With Worgenite breaking the "no PMing" rule/guideline, it's unlikely that each player has found Faraway to be Scum independently of each other.

[listo95]

I think that the fact that two players seem to have come up with faraway independent of each other should count for something here, shouldn't it?

The way I got faraway may not mean they are scum/mad hatter. For all we know he is telling the truth about having a power role. But with tracking I can never get the full answer unless I track a person who killed a person on the same night. But I just wonder why everyone is saying only worgen and lysah would be targets if faraway come back town,only real reason is the voting with no reason (that I can think of). At least for me I had information to go with my vote.