Here's my plan, let's make one spec rely on managing mana, one rely on gaming its crit chance and one based around managing procs and a pet.
I'd quite enjoy an Arcane spec that had mana that went up with a speed more like Destro's Chaotic Energy (though obviously with more of a focus on keeping it high, than a focus on making sure it didn't run out), though what we've got at the moment is still enough to satisfy me until 6.0 on Beta when I'll be able to make that suggestion to the dev team and have it given proper attention.
They would certainly either have to have Mastery at increments or simply balance around you not having 100% benefit, the problem with the latter (and current) system being that players will always search for ways to stay at 100% mana at all times and thus do more damage than they are balanced to do.
Like Scorch weaving at present! And Invocation tapping on the PTR if they don't find a way to patch that out.
One way of solving that is with increments and that seems a fairly sensible way to do it, though it might simply delay the value mages try and ensure they are above by gaming tactics!
There has to be some reason the Mage would ever dip into the 50% boundary and not feel that he was failing or Mastery simply becomes a passive "+% damage" stat. Which... it basically is for some classes, but I'd rather it wasn't because that's just a bit boring.
Maybe Mana Adept would simply become a flat bonus and Mastery would increase mana regen? But it'd have to be by fairly small amounts to outweigh the other stats, and you can't really decouple regen from Haste either or that's heavily devalued...
There's probably a way to do that, but I haven't quite figured it out yet.
As regards the 50%, perhaps Arcane Power could be a cooldown that lasts for much longer, but you lose it if you gain more than 50% of mana.
Do no harm, but take no shit.
Omg, what has Blizzard done to mages (I haven't played mine since Cata)?
Really? Show me a fight where you have to move fore more than 1 second before you can stop, cast and go again? Show me ONE FIGHT where you cannot position yourself in a way to do this? Now, tell me what the CD is on using Scorch? What did I hear you say, a global? OMG, it turns out that during that 1 second moving, you can still cast a mana free scorch that let's you gain mana back so you can continue to AB, lets even say you've to move for 2 seconds, maybe even 3? Oh look, you can cast 2-3 Scorches, be back to full Mana and still sitting on 6 stacks.... Does this mean you may have to keep 2 runes up? Yes it does, but again, PLAYER SKILL is what matters most here, understanding wheat he movement is coming, preparing for it with your positioning and your runes, don't be fucking stupid and try to say we have no mobility, actually read your spells and cop the fuck on. You also have your bombs, last time I checked, aren't they instant casts too? Oh, yes they are... Why not refresh one of those if its falling off when your moving?
Okay, so with the Saracasm aside, I do not disagree that other classes have better mobility for us, but ours is absolutely fine if you just use your head and play with skill instead of tunnelling into DPS mode and then shouting at your computer when you have to move!
According to you logic, every caster class in the game is exactly the same then, because all of the follow the rotation you mentioned.... Affli Lock, Apply Dots, hit lightly up button (Haunt), spam filler, use Dark Soul off CD, Ele Shaman, apply shock, hit lightly up button, use filler etc etc, Shadow Preists exactly the same.
So, you say in the first part of your post that the Mages skill makes no difference whatsoever, then you say we can't trust sims as they do t account for human error and player skill? I'm actually LOLing right now.... There is absolutely no doubt that Sims are not the best way to look at DPS, but they do still show what's theoretically possible and it is a starting point. Lets forget about Sims for a min and look at just logs and parses, still think that Arcane is not top? Cop the fuck on mate... Still think fire isn't top for cleave fights? Seriously, wake up...
Mages are still the OP class right now, weather you want to believe it or not, raidbots confirms it, rankings confirm it, everything does, so stop your bitching. If you where my GM, and I seen you take an SP or Ele Shaman over the Mage for Raids, I'd be the firsth person telling you how fucking stupid you are mate, SP damage is so rubbish right now for Single Target it's not even funny, yes they shine on Elegon and Will cause of the multi dotting and the flow of the fights but that's it. And will people cop the fuck on about their Tranquility, have any of you actually bothered to look over logs of how much a SPs Tranq actually does? Obviously not if you keep saying how big an impact it has... Tell you what, I won't completely ruin the surprise for ye, go onto WoL, find a log where an SP used Tranq, see how much it actually did and then come back here and try tell me that's a reason to bring the Preist over the Top DPS class for 90% of the fights right now.
And FYI, I base my numbers and those around me from my own guild in HC progression, yes we're not a world top 1000 guild but we re decent. I do a lot of LFR to test out cross realm applicants for my guild, I have a specific set of instructions I give them on specific fights to test different areas of their play style before we make a decision to accept them or not. 11-15% of total damage done in LFR would be very low for me, and that's as Fire. I base absolutely noting I say around LFR however, I base it all around my HC Raid Observations, raidbots and logs.
The fact that evo's cast time got cut in half will certainly help reduce the RNG factor though.
How about when Elegon throws a spark at you?
The occasional baddie that got too close to you, despite being nowhere close to the way he was SUPPOSED to be kiting.
It fucking happens dude, it's called RNG. Don't fucking use such a shitty cop out like that.
I wish I could see into the mind of the devs. I want to know what their intention is for each L90 talent. Why pick RoP over Invocation?
http://oce.op.gg/summoner/userName=dw+soul+roc in oceanic now Lol
5172-1206-0622 pokemon FC Lets Battle!!
Only locks can fully dps on the move (its impossible to screw up movement as a lock - even if you're bad).
Only locks bring a unique spell (healthstone - every raid and their mom pick HS as it's a free pot).
Oh yeah, we bring ring of frost. lol
---------- Post added 2013-01-20 at 01:36 PM ----------
Also, you guys focusing too much in this tier. Many many fights in this game were pretty movement intensive. Unless you started playing in MoP, you guys should know this...
MOving while doing full dps is gamebraking - and its is a HUGE QoL improvement whether you see it or not.