The second voice is chocolate to my ears, BRAVO
Slightly unrelated but thought I'd share. Lor'themar apparently recorded an album during those years of inactivity.
Smooth jazz will be deployed in 3 ... 2 ... 1 ...
I agree with Robutt, someone get a machinima team on this stat.
Aside from the lulzy things above, the second voice is far and away better. It has a faint accent, which just makes things shiny. His voice is a bit lighter and sophisticated sounding, which even being a former Ranger-general, any blood elf has a certain level of sophistication. The other one sounds a little generic and sounds like a human.