I think people are underestimating how bad the Warrior nerfs actually are.

[PaladinBash]

Good players will still do good with Warriors. Hell...some people do good with Ele Shamans or Ret Paladins and those specs are absolutely terrible at high ratings. Rogues were pretty bad yet there were still good rogues...now the class is OP again watch how they suddenly pop up again. Enter a BG and see how many Rogues you see. Just as many Warriors as you used to see.

All the complaining of Warriors now is just noob tears. Class was OP the entirety of the expansion and baddies were probably still unable to kill decent players of other classes and now they won't be able to...so they will complain the nerfs were too severe. It happens all the time. It'll happen if Rogues get made bad again. It'll happen to whatever class comes after Rogues as a free ride to Gladiator. The excuse of "our class used to suck" just doesn't work. Remember 3.0 when Ret Paladins could just run around soloing 3-4 people in full Brutal at once? I do. It was the greatest week of the entire game. Nothing will ever feel so sweet as the tears of every other player who could not win against me because I was just that OP. That's how Warriors have been all this expansion and just because they had a few bad seasons (ever) doesn't mean they shouldn't be dragged down from the top spot like they have been.

Do they need more nerfs? Not really. They're still good now and you shouldn't just outright make a spec suck "because it was good" just as you shouldn't make a terrible spec amazing just because it sucks.

TL;DR warriors are still good but not OP

[Hjelpen]

Funny, Warriors still miles ahead of Ret palas in terms of Mobility/Burst/Sustain dmg/ Defensive CDS/

[schwank05]

Warrior has always been my favorite tank, I also fell that they should never dps just not how I feel they were designed. Our MT is a warrior and pretty much wrecked my DPS on all fights in MSV except 2nd boss where I had the extra button attacks to help, IM a Pally. He even won overall dps on stone guard and Will quite often. Now after the changes I beat him on damage on every single pull by nearly 6-7k DPS. This makes me want to level my warrior even less.

[pkm]

Warrior has always been my favorite tank, I also fell that they should never dps just not how I feel they were designed. Our MT is a warrior and pretty much wrecked my DPS on all fights in MSV except 2nd boss where I had the extra button attacks to help, IM a Pally. He even won overall dps on stone guard and Will quite often. Now after the changes I beat him on damage on every single pull by nearly 6-7k DPS. This makes me want to level my warrior even less.

I don't understand why people bring pve into a pvp thread. What are you trying to accomplish?