weapon question

[Deleted]

prot warri here having problems as fury in single tank fights .

armory http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte.../Chikin/simple

i got ilvl 492 equiped as fury but some of my items are gemmed/reforged etc for tanking . that leaves me with underwhelming 17,74 % crit unbuffed .
last night i got both hc weapons from elegon (lucky me) and now i am unsure what weapon to use .

normaly i would say elegon 1hand (hc) + kilrak (nhc) , but starshatter (hc) + starshatter (nhc) have freaking 1800 crit .

suggestions ?

[Deleted]

I'd pick 1800 crit any day if I was at 17,7% crit. If you had correct reforges, gems and enchants then the 1h's would pull ahead. (nhc) does that mean not heroic? Just write normal.