To clarify on points made towards my post in no specific order.
-I am not a person who joined in cata I have been in the game since late vanilla when it was about to go BC and have been raiding since bc content.
-I do like the idea of it being an elder charm/valor instead of gold or even a higher gold requirement like 1k gold.
-As for the whole complaining about not getting loot thing my only loot complaint is seeing the same couple of pieces drop every other week while I know I'm selling it off to a vendor and some poor soul could have used a piece from that boss.
- I am not a lfr only hero I do raid the actual content in a 10 man raid.
-I have seen plenty of people that if their life depended on getting a piece of lfr gear in one month they would be in the grave because they can't get anything.
-The idea for the loot queue (pick the spec you want but go in on another spec) isn't a bad idea at all.
-Maybe implement a tracker so that you can't do the trades until you have downed the boss x amount of times (like 4 times or so)