Hey guys, my guild has spent 6 hours working on H Will so far but the lowest we got was 55% and it's been sloppy at best. I can't for the life of me figure out what we can do better. 37 pulls but we're not beating that learning curve as quickly as expected.
Our raid composition has the following (rotatable as needed)
Mistweaver Monks x 2
Holy Paladins x 2
Restoration Druid x 1
(We are only bringing in 5 healers, shaman was out last night but he's available tonight)
Warlocks x 5 (we had 3 in last night)
Boomkins x 2 (one has a very geared feral OS)
Feral Cat x 1
Hunters x 3 (I can't explain the hunter soaking but after the 3rd died, two of the hunters were rotating just fine without him so idk)
Mages x 2 (one fire, one arcane)
Spriest x 1
Warrior x 2 (one went Prot for strength)
Death Knight x 4 (one went Blood for strength)
Ret Paladin x 1
Windwalker Monk x 1
Elemental Shaman x 2
This was our best try: http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/r...?s=8563&e=9222 and a screenshot I took at the end of the night as a reminder of who was in http://rancidracing.com/WoW/WoWScrnS...213_225606.jpg so you can see our composition. We had to sit the spriest because she was always dead, which was basically useless.
I just don't know how to make this any easier for the people in my guild. We're killing rages as they come out. We're running into an issue after we start getting courages out it seems. We have warlocks slowing them but they aren't dying fast enough if there is a dance going on at the same time. After we start losing too many people, we basically end up wiping. We went from 65% to 55% though with most of the same people up who weren't messing things up and only have two hunters who are successfully soaking while the 3rd always fails and ends up dead. I'm not an expert at this game so I can't explain people's classes to them.
Maybe our DPS is too low although it shouldn't be. Any advice is appreciated! Thank you in advance.