I'm extremely skeptical about it being #1. Maybe if they are using some really high EP value for spell hit? But that is kind of silly because since you are (or at least should be) already hit capped, the hit on the trinket isn't really adding spell hit but various other stats (also worst case, you might have enough base hit on your gear that you can't reforge all the extra off and some of it is being used for white hit). Now you didn't mention spec, but I would guess the blood lust one and the mastery with agi proc + voodoo gnomes ones are better.
That said, it should be a good bit better than the dark moon relic.