The women in the linked picture are probably more representative of the larger population of women in America. I would have no problems with any of those women, they are all very beautiful. It's when you start to see the flabby triceps and a more prominent "gut" or "muffin top" that it becomes unattractive. There are small things like that which, to my mind, indicate a more unhealthy lifestyle. It may not be the case, but that's the perception. I may be shallow for it, but I could never be with someone who is too much more overweight than the women in the linked picture (and I don't necessarily consider them overweight!)