I am going to create a poll about a hypothetical scenario concerning 2 members of a raiding guild.
Raider A is less skilled but more active than Raider B.
Raider B is more skilled but less active than Raider A.
Both are skilled enough to down normal content but Raider A might struggle on heroic progression while Raider B might have it easier.
Both are active enough but Raider B might miss a few progression raids due to real life obligations.
Which raider out of those two would your prefer to your raiding guild?
I am curious how activity is valued over skill and vice versa.
The reason I am not having a neither option is because I guess top guilds usually have raiders both skilled and active, therefore the dillema wouldn't apply to them.
I guess to clarify from a scale of 1 to 10 with 10 being perfect
Raider A: 7 skill 9 activity
Raider B: 9 skill 7 activity