Thanks for the quick replies and helpful information. We'll probably stay away from TSG, the DK is pretty adamant on Unholy, I think. 2 questions:
1. Yvaelle mentioned Frost Mage as a pretty solid choice as a 3rd candidate. What is Frost Mage, Holy, Unholy like?
2. Based on this information, I'm heavily considering Hunter (BM I assume?) and Frost Mage, but was also interested on SPriest and Warlock play. How would these 4 comps compare in ease of play? I am the holy paladin in this comp, btw.
Thanks for all the feedback