I've had this problem for awhile now after I won "Jin'ya, Orb of the Waterspeaker" off a roll a couple months back. Nothing seems to compare to it given what I've had to work with.
I won Shield of Twinned Despair last night. Problem is, I have Regail's Crackling Dagger. (not heroic)
After taking into account reforges, gems, enchants, etc... Here are the numbers I've come up with:
+ 19,188 Armor (physical damage reduction 49.44%)
+ 844 Spirit
+ 40 Haste
- 275 Mastery
- 59 Stamina
- 207 Intellect
- 1296 Spell Power
- 319 Crit
As you can see the armor and spirit gains are pretty awesome!
The spell power is a huge loss though. D:
How much of a difference will that make? Admittedly, I'm not a phenomenal math wiz, so any help would be awesome. Also, does physical damage only imply direct hits from mobs or ANY damage what-so-ever? I want to assume it means all, but I've been wrong before on stuff like this.
Thanks for any help you may have!