I think most movies are books before they are films, but seriously video game movies and in a league of their own for suck ass and it doesn't make any sense. We can probably thank Uwe Bol. It is like they try and capture the gameplay or some element that doesn't translate - even for people that enjoy the game underneath. It is like they miss a step where they take recognition that it is a movie. Take max payne for example. The game is almost written like a story board, you would think that if anything would make a good movie this would be it, but when it came it was all "atmosphere" and no substance which completely robbed the chance of it ever selling itself. The script probably fit on one side of A4 and never drove that atmosphere or any attachment to it so I know I was bored as hell with it. To me this was the very epitome of video movie lameness. I can at least laugh at that steroid infused chainsaw clip in the doom movie even if it was incredibly campy.
If the wow movie can take stock of the fact that it is a movie and not a video game then maybe there is hope but I am yet to see it happen.
:O Accidental cleverness?