This achievement just stinks "One that didn't get away". I know its a very random drop rate but please, I have spend hours and hours trying for the Dark Herring and 15Lb Mud Snapper and no luck. I really don't think a fishing achievement should take this long no matter what it is. I did some math and 8k cast with 4 casts per min is 33hrs. That's just sad. Ranting is done tks.