Originally Posted by
Soulzar
I know exactly what thread you are talking about and to be honest I am unsure why you are asking the question you are asking. The post by Gahhda clearly explained the demo lock required the trinket to be a key factor in the strat and even had math one how much RDPS is required .... There was also math on how much DPS would be required if they did not have a demo lock with the trinket to abuse its mechanics.
Looking at WoL ranking since that post came out, its more apparent that the tanks vengeance dps is the biggest factor in this strat as Gahhda has been dethroned from #1 by a good bit, by none other than Paladin tanks.
My opinion would be, without the trinket Affliction would be the best. Affliction's ability to burst and take advantage of opening pull snapshots with hero is significantly better than demo without the trinket to snapshot high hasted crit Dooms. While the 2p makes it possible to have a respectable opening burst, you certainly don't have the fury or molten core procs to spam Soulfire with Darksoul up the full 20 seconds, ToC is not benefiting from Hero.. and anything cast outside of Meta is obviously not getting its dmg modifier which you would want to be in with all buffs up like they are. While spamming dooms around without the 100% crit snapshot will summon a respectable army of imps, the ramp up time will be much longer for the short duration of the fight and I would be surprised if you could out pace Affliction in effective boss dmg.