Page 11 of 25 FirstFirst ...
9
10
11
12
13
21
... LastLast
  1. #201
    Classic - Did not play
    BC - 8/10
    WotlK - 9/10
    Cata - 5/10
    MoP - 7/10

  2. #202
    Keyboard Turner
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Location
    California
    Posts
    1
    Vanilla - 8.5/10
    TBC - 9/10
    WOTLK- 7.5/10 (9/10 In regards to Ulduar and ICC)
    Cata - 3.5/10
    MoP - 7/10

  3. #203
    Classic - I didn't attend
    BC - 6.5/10 (started playing shortly before sunwell release)
    Wrait - 8/10 (some neat additions to the game, also picked up the WC3 Story. Cons: Story ending)
    Cata - 4/10 (it failed horribly as an rpg, through Firelands saved it from total fail)
    Mists - 7/10 (I wasn't a Panadren hater to begin with but I was sceptical - until I got into it)

  4. #204
    Pandaren Monk Telaq's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    The Big Apple!(Former Swede)
    Posts
    1,839
    Vanilla : 10/10
    TBC : 10/10
    Wotlk 11/10
    Cata : 8.5/10
    MoP : 9/10

  5. #205
    Vanilla = 7/10
    B/C = 8/10
    LK = 5/10
    Cata = 4/10
    MoP = 6/10

    WoW was in a good place in BC. I disliked the direction they started to take the game in LK, making much of the content trivial and non-challenging. Cata just didn't work as an expansion due to overall lack of content, and looking back I think it was a mistake to revamp the old continents as much as they did and the 1-60 questing is just a joke now. MoP is ok, but PvP is horribly broken and going through big changes so it's hard to get any fun out of that aspect of the game, and raiding isn't as fun when I've been doing it for 6+ years.

  6. #206
    Quote Originally Posted by Wildmoon View Post
    Vanilla 10/10
    BC 8/10
    WotLK 6/10
    Cataclysm 5/10
    MoP 9/10

    This is based on quality AND how much I enjoy each one.

    Pretty much what mine is. Maybe switch TBC and MoP's numbers.

  7. #207
    Stood in the Fire Dairyking101's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    Canada, Eh?
    Posts
    410
    Vanilla = 7/10
    B/C = 8/10
    LK = 8/10
    Cata = 6/10
    MoP = 9/10

  8. #208
    vanilla 9/10
    TBC 10/10
    Wotlk 9/10
    cata 0/10
    MoP 7/10

  9. #209
    Stood in the Fire Theleklol's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Under your bed
    Posts
    499
    1.0 - Can't be rated, due in part to my fascination my first MMO and all the joy it brought to me. The other part is the inaccessibility of many parts of the game, without blind dedication. Naxxramas 40, in particular, was one of the raids I never got to participate in while it was current content.
    2.0 - 8/10. Probably the best expansion as a whole, pve and pvp were entertaining and fresh.
    3.0 - 7/10. All the grinding of the previous expansions was laid to rest, all fun, no risk. Ulduar was pure genius.
    3.2 - 3/10. Trial of the Crusader. Not much to this one, probably designed by a monkey.
    4.0 - 5/10. Healing was exceptionally painful after the healer mana rework. I got stuck as a holy paladin, which wasn't too bad, but I had to work my ass off to rank in 4.0 raiding.
    4.2 - 7/10. Firelands was probably one of the better raids WoW has put together, in my opinion. Fights felt epic again, no more painful Bastion of Twilight clears.
    5.0 - 7/10. Class redesign was welcome after Cataclysm, talent builds have flexibility at different levels of play. Warlocks are very enjoyable, raids feel epic, not just trash, boss, trash, boss, trash, boss.
    Temple of Light-ShadowsongUS
    Get Along Gang-ShadowsongUS (Disbanded)
    ~Alanaria~:::Cyclønite:::Thelek

  10. #210
    Vanilla = 9.5/10
    B/C = 9.5/10
    LK = 10/10
    Cata = 2/10
    MoP = 9.5/10

  11. #211
    Classic(didn't really play much) - 7/10
    BC - 8/10 (pvp and raiding was great)
    Wotlk - 9.5/10 (Raiding was pretty awesome, and pvp was fun)
    Cata - 6/10 (Raiding was okay)
    MoP - 4/10 (But I am enjoying raiding)

  12. #212
    Vanilla - 8
    TBC - 9
    Wrath - 7(Only because of Ulduar did it get this high of a rating)
    Cata - 4(Just because of transmog)
    Pandara - 5

  13. #213
    Immortal Quetzl's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Mass, US
    Posts
    7,043
    Vanilla -8/10
    TBC - 9/10
    Wrath - 9/10
    Cata - 6/10
    MOP - Haven't played

  14. #214
    Vanilla (Though not technically an expansion) - 7
    TBC - 9
    WotLK - 8
    Cata - 5
    MoP - 4
    ...I can almost picture a very sad swede thinking "Thou shall not succumb to mediocrity". With a sadface indeed.

  15. #215
    Vanilla - 9
    TBC - 9
    Wrath - 8
    Cata - 4
    Panda - 2

  16. #216
    Vanilla - 10
    TBC - 10
    Wrath - 9
    Cata - 3
    Pandas & P8k@mon - 1

  17. #217
    Vanilla: 8/10 - For back then amazing world with interesting quests and dungeons but alot of small issues although those didn't lessen the fun of playing.
    BC: 9.5/10 - Fixed the small issues I had with vanilla and was the perfect game to get me addicted: great character progression, good story and good playstyle/encounters.
    WOTLK: 8/10 - Kept going alot of things I liked in BC some changes I disliked, some I liked but in the end the lack of good progression means a lesser grade.
    Cata: 5/10 - Interesting story but the questlines didn't really work for me, beautiful zones though which get the grade up but disliked almost all changes to the game.
    MoP: 6/10 - Way better then cata but still not good. Lack of reasons to want to perform in content and the end of class playstyles I liked. Good zones and decent story.

  18. #218
    I am Murloc! Wildberry's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    On Board the Hate Train.
    Posts
    5,349
    PreBC: 8/10
    TBC: 9/10
    WotLK: 9/10 (For different reasons thatn TBC)
    Cataclysm: 2/10 (Those two points are for Goblins and Transmog, there wasn't much else.)
    MoP: 7/10

  19. #219
    Vanilla - 6/10
    BC - 10/10
    Wrath - 8/10
    Cata - 4/10
    MoP - 7/10

  20. #220
    Field Marshal blixsauce's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    63
    Vanilla - Didn't play
    TBC - 7/10 (half way through)
    WoTLK- 8.5/10
    Cata - 5/10
    MoP - 8/10

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •