Originally Posted by
Rucati
DKP systems aren't really necessary. My guild usually just /rolls on gear, but the winner passes it to whoever needs it most anyway most of the time. We're all adults, gear doesn't matter much as long as we are progressing, so whoever gets stuff is fine. My favorite system would probably be loot council, that way the people who need it always get it, but any immature guilds are going to have problems with people complaining about it not being fair. I haven't used DKP since Burning Crusade, just not really worth the effort.
Your guild will either complain no matter what system is used, or your guild won't have any problems with any system, not much middle ground. If there's a lot of gear whores or distrust people will dislike every system because they can all be negative towards those people, if everyone is chill and relaxed they won't care much about the system regardless.