Anyway, didnt blizz say that all the bonuses to professions, tailor proc, engi synapse, alch mini flask, JC extra gems, BS wrist, etc all even out to be the same increase? In that case Engi > all since it's controllable.
Please remember- cloak never has dispelled. It REMOVES any SPELL effect. So it works on diseases (which are spells but not magic) poisons (which are spells but not magic) and numerous other effects that are only in the spell category but lack a dispel type completely (such as rocket fuel leak, acquiring target, the paladin seal dot, scorched, TONS of effects like this).
Dragonslayer Hoddie - pretending to know what I'm doing!
Take both engi and tailoring,
engi gloves = on use trinket
so if you are human you can have 2 proc trinkets (pvp one and pve one)
+ engi on use
+ weapon enchant proc
Using this setup on my rogue atm, and if i have 3-4 procs up and then use engi gloves + burst
then the dmg is just silly. Ofc you need to be lucky for all the procs to be up when you want to go for a burst.
as others have stated, in certain guides it is mentioned that it could statistically be the best, however because of its random proc nature its not useful for PvP unless the stars and RNG gods align with your burst it could technically be considered a loss if its not active when you need it most
Yea, on topic, engineering is the best. Obviously rocket boots is ludic, as is the glider or parachute, but in the good-gear-making types of PvP (the instanced stuff, not the world stuff) these are disabled.
So it's all about the glove tinker. While you can line up the glove tinker with everything but an activated trinket (which have been nerfed so often that they are pretty substandard right now), you'll have a harder time lining the tailoring enchant up. Additionally, the tailoring enchant is normally raw AP (instead of mainstat) if you are a Str or Agi guy.
Still, if you are comfortable capitalizing on or using it, it is a very good trick. I see plenty of good players make use of it- normally casters, however.
Alchemy + Herbalism > all over you nubcakes, as a Tauren my herb speed is beyond imgination
Time is on our side
Brutal Gladiator Enhancement Shaman *rawr*
This isn't even up for debate. First pvp prof = engi for controllable burst and lining up with one of your cooldowns (since you'd want to line up big burst with trinket). It's quite easy to force defensive cooldowns with well timed Synapse + Other short CD for good damage and then use your trinket + big burst for kill windows.
Second profession maybe good for tailoring.