Help my Prot Pally Please

[morph757]

Hello,
I have a prot pally player who is struggling with his Prot pally on Heroics. With his gear, he should be doing better at mitigation, threat, and damage, however he does not excel as well as he should in either of those areas. The player himself is very talented. Plays just about every class, originally tanked on a druid for many expansions and for this expansion tanked on a brewmaster who he has mastered however we recently switched him to pally a month ago for bop (because we lost our pally healer) and because we wanted a plate tank and a lw tank. with that said, the simple solution is "just have him tank on his brew" which we do not want to do. It just works better for our raid in the future if he is a pally, warrior, or dk.

anyways, What is he doing wrong, and what could he be doing better? I think it has to do with his rotation and how he attacks enemies, etc. His gear set is going towards a "balanced" set up. He has had trouble keeping threat on adds on heroic horridon. OR, if he is on Horridon, he would randomly just die sometimes while tanking heroic horridon (while on the doors, not while horridon is enraged)

Here is a link to his Armory
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...lness/advanced

I will post 2 sets of logs. One set is us learning and wiping on horridon.
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/r...ses&boss=68476

the second set of logs is him tanking horridon on his pally like 3 attempts, then he switches to his brew.

http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/r...ses&boss=68476


any real feedback would be greatly appreciated.

[Fhi]

Please search the front page at the very least before creating new threads. There is already a thread dedicated to character help here:
http://www.mmo-champion.com/threads/...Fix-my-Tanking!