The common man is like a worm in the gut of a corpse, trapped inside a prison of cold flesh, helpless and uncaring, unaware even of the inevitability of its own doom.
The bat riders cannot carry large, heavy plague tanks, only a limited stock of small bombs. Sure they may come in swarms and the bombs would be very volatile, but then again they would be shot down by Alliance air forces before they could provide any significant damage.
People seem to overestimate Sylvanas and the Forsaken as a war force. Sure, she has the val'kyr, but there's no way in hell she would ever again bring them to the front lines after the Andorhal incident, less they would get decimated above everything else as the Alliance troops would mark them as primary targets. Plus the human corpses (keep in mind the val'kyr cannot raise any other than humans) would be burned by their fellow troops, rendering them useless for reanimation.
So, no. She could not be able to conquer the whole of EK (the Horde would be very unlikely to support her), where the Alliance military force is far more powerful than hers.
If this has been said, it hasn't been said enough:
She won't be able to capture Light's Hope Chapel. Period. End of Thread.
Sylvanas would have to deal with all the dwarven clans, Stormwind, gnomes, Gilnean survivors, and any rebel faction groups spread throughout the Eastern Kingdoms. The dwarves alone could crush her.
Eventually, I think so. Currently? No chance.
A lot of people seem to just assume that she'll use the same tactics she used around the North. Not a good assumption, in my opinion. I think the reason we haven't seen much of her lately is because she's licking her wounds, updating her battle strategy, and strengthening her forces.
I think it's eventually possible, but it may be farther than a decade game time before it could occur feasibly, with any kind of success. Unfortunately, I think she'll also be one of Blizzard's new targets before that comes to pass, we shall see. I also believe that if she does become a Blizzard target, whatever is beneath Western Tirisfal is what pushes her to "raid boss" status.
It's been over two years in game since the Forsaken initial conquest portrayed in Cataclysm. They took no part in any offensive in Either Cataclysm or Mists other than sending some singular officers or a token force at best. Logically, Sylvanas spent that time by strengthening her grip over Lordaeron. The forces holding Alterac are nothing. And neither are Alliance forces in Arathi. Refugee Pointe is a hole in the ground that is immensely vulnerable to "roll plague tanks and pour the plague down on human heads" tactic.
However, Dwarves and Humans did fight on multiple fronts all over Azeroth in that time. Their forces are diminished and exhausted. I'm not saying Sylvanas has the power to seize entire Eastern Kingdoms. But she does have the power to capture most of Lordaeron. The only reason Arathi and Alterac are not Forsaken territory yet is because Blizzard totally ignored her since Cata. She could also capture Caer Darrow (for some reason I can't picture Argent Crusaders drooling over the idea of taking Scholomance for themselves). And then Hitnerlands would be trapped and fall eventually. And she really should blow the remaining bridge of the Thandol Span sky high. There's nothing that would prevent her from reaching that goal on her side of it. And even though she could potentially capture parts of Wetlands, it would be safer for her to just sever the connection between Lordaeron and rest of the Eastern Kingdoms.
And yes, Argent Crusade has a longstanding history of interference in the international politics of the main factions. I totally see your point.
The Knights of the Ebon Blade used the tactics of the Scourge and of the Forsaken in their campaign. They even compared themselves to the Forsaken a few times. Why would they give a shit about Sylvanas plaguing people the death knights don't care about or resurrecting them? They would have done the same were they ever fighting anyone again. They came with the idea of Shadowmourne, their take at Frostmourne, did they not? And in the case Sylvanas lost, when they'd be the last undead Faction, what would stop them from thinking "When will they come for us?". Or thinking that preemptively, before she lost.
And they have never shown necromantic capabilities on the scale of the Val'kyr. They were quite successful at freeing individual undead from Lich King's grasp, but the Forsaken already have free will.
Im sure us belves wouldn't mind serving our former ranger general.
She couldn't even take out the much smaller forces of Gilneans with the full might of undercity.
Probably not, its just not feasible for just the Forsaken to win a large scale war against the Alliances power base, Humans and Dwarves.
I don't think any race can defeat the mighty dwarfs in battle.
They will just stand far far in the back with their battle tanks/steam tanks, and when they are getting near they just open fire, Enough tanks/cannons they can use to destroy the enemy without even losing 1 single men.
Dwarfs are stronger then they seem like.
EU ~ Outland
(ofcourse speculation & would've been helps no one and would never go through due to gameplay) she's not some superpower like the Lich king was, and i doubt they will make her into one.
If I were sylvanas advisor, I'd suggest conquering northrend instead. No faction resides there anymore, the scourge is not eliminated by sure, sylvanas can deal with that. There are still many natives there,vyrkul and zuldark trolls for example that she could raise and the only resistance I'd imagine will be in grizzly hills where the alliance is probably consuming last resources such as trees. And of course the dragon aspects . Of course, who the hell know what goes on there anymore. Dalaran is in dustwallow marsh in the current events.
Then again, why would she attack the alliance at all? She doesn't hold any grudge whatsoever to the alliance, and I think she'd rather conquer silvermoon instead.
Last edited by Barendon; 2013-07-26 at 12:52 PM.
If the Forsaken actually marched on something and commit to attacking it I think their forward fortifications would end up decimated under the shadow of The Skyfire or Dalaran or both.
The notion that they could hold the land around Ironforge long enough to starve the dwarves out is flatly stupid. Ironforge was made from the ground up to be a stronghold. You think they never thought that someday they would have to hole up in there and defend themselves for an extended period of time? That's literally what the purpose of the structure is. It's also a fantasy spellcasting staple that food and drink can easily be magically produced. I can believe that the population of Westfall could stave but Ironforge? They have enough trained magicians that there is no chance of that.
My crappy gaming blog: PuppetShowJustice.com
Now covering Hearthstone!
Leaving a comment would make my day. Seriously.