I don't have gold with my moonkin and I have been raiding heroic since forever, truth be told I didn't invested too much time trying.
I find really stupid the proving grounds, they are not realistic in any way.
for casual gold may be a bit tough. but its defidently smart if you want a smart and efficient group
Why Proving grounds?
Why not brawlers guild?
Surely brawlers guild actually tests your awareness and ability to not stand in the nasty stuff, atleast it should do it better compared to kitting balls into mobs that don't move.
Ofc this doesn't work for healers and tanks but hey.
Still think it's a weird idea regardless.
Last edited by glowzone; 2013-09-15 at 01:54 PM.
I just returned to the game after 6 months of logging in maybe 1 time every 2 weeks (just afked in shrine), 1 shot everything through gold, got to wave 18 first time on endless mode and 24 as my best attempt (only like 5 total attempts). Shits cake.
/wow/en/character/sargeras/Traxèx/simple (cant post links)
stopped playing a couple weeks after last tiers heroic content started.
I might be a DK and "Dks are good at solo content" but proving grounds isnt about solo content. It's about how well you manage your cooldowns and prioritizing adds and avoiding certain abilities while still maintaining high DPS (from a DPS perspective).Not everybody is good at doing solo content, I personally struggled with getting gold on my balance druid.
I'm a team player and have always been, so I don't see the point in excluding possible recruitments, you are merely denying yourself.
and for those of you who don't know, in endless mode, every wave the adds health increases by 1% so I was up to 24% increased health. Could've gotten further but I messed up :[
Last edited by Traxex9080; 2013-09-15 at 02:02 PM.
It's your guild, man. Set the rules you want and stick to them if you truly believe they are warranted. That's your choice. Obviously, don't cry if people tell you where you can stick your proving grounds requirements and leave. That's their choice.
I'm pretty sure I saw an interview where GC or another dev said that this might be one of the potential uses of PG, along with possibly making it the gating requirement for LFR over ilvl.
Last edited by DetectiveJohnKimble; 2013-09-15 at 02:01 PM.
RAIDLEADER: k guys everyone do proving grounds they're really cool
Baddy: NO PROVING GROUNDS ARE JUST UNSKILLED UNBALANCED THINGS NOBODY SHOULD HAVE TO DO THEM
That's pretty much how I imagine it happening in every guild where someone is just bad and wants to think of excuses to get out of doing it. It's like someone who is really dumb saying "TESTS DON'T MEAN ANYTHING" trying to sound like an erudite philosopher saying that tests are rarely indicative of actual ability or knowledge. The reality is it's just someone dumb who doesn't want to admit what they are. Same goes with Proving Grounds. It IS easy to get gold. Oh boohoo you can't do ultra maximised super finely balanced DPS...big deal. You don't need to. I think a lot of PVE babbies have no idea how to play without gear and are just butthurt that simple raid mechanics are beyond them.
Paladin Bash has spoken.
OP your guild sounds very casual. Good luck with that.
The only thing PG shows is how well people can perform the test at Norushen, otherwise it's proves nothing.
It's easier to find a thousand flaws in another person than to find one in yourself.
well considering the leader boards are dominated by dks (check top 100 endless scores) it says a lot about class balance in there. if you look through you can see which class struggles and then when you htink about said classes ability and game play it becomes obvious.
If someone can't complete the proving grounds then they aren't raid ready, plain and simple.
Did it only once for shit and giggles, just to see what it is all about... Tried as healer, and wiped twice on Silver..
I have no clue, since the wipes happened once due to expired time, and I cannot control where my group stands. If they stand in fire like the stupid enemy king moving into a fire square during Kara chess, my healing skills are rather insufficient. And Resto Druids aren't exactly the kings of damage dealing in healer spec.
I can throw some Farie Fires, a Moonfire here and there, and for a little while I can even help with dps popping HotW.
It may be easy, when giving a little more thought, otherwise it certainly is not as easy as some make it sound it is.
To require Gold in the main spec of a players toon, for a heavily progression oriented guild may be okay. I can see that. But for a casual guild that raids once a week with little progression motivation I think it's an overkill, and may be the death of the raid team.
Let alone that I do not think how Blizzard put proving grounds into the game to be abused as just another unreasonable requirement made up in players minds.
"The pen is mightier than the sword.. and considerably easier to write with."
It became clear that it wasn’t realistic to try to get the audience back to being more hardcore, as it had been in the past. -- Tom Chilton
Training Dummy/Proving grounds will always be different than Raids.
However, I think it's good to at least prove you have decent damage/awareness to get gold, perhaps you should be less strict but try to make the guild get better gear etc etc?
New season. Fun times.
" Who would of thought a small kid from Aberdeen, Washington, who was always labelled a B+ player, who would of thought that guy could of main evented Wrestlemania? Nobody. Nobody except ...you guys."