Now, based I what I have right now, I've gone for using #1 and #3, since Cha-Ye's still gives me a tonne of crit, and Toxic gives me the nice proc (on boss fights it's contributing to roughly ~4% of my damage). But I'm still not convinced that's necessarily the right choice, so any advice based on what I have now would be useful.
While I'm at, assuming I get PBoS, I'm still confused as to what my 2nd trinket should be. Using anything other than Cha-Ye's would be a big crit loss, but I would guess I should aim for BBoY and reforge to crit? Or would toxic still be better?
Right now use Cha-ye and Totem. When you get Bindings use it with Cha-ye and only replace Cha-ye with Black Blood. Not sure how Cleave trinket dose with fire but its only good for 2 fights, Galakras and Spoils, but even then i wouldn't think it would be worth dropping BB for.
"Vykina, do you have a list of best trink comb's ? Like from BiS > Worst"
Purified bindings of immerseus > Black Blood > Toxic totem > Frenzied Crystal of rage ( the crystal is barely good at spoils)
Seems clear? And by the way, you'd want to use Toxic & Breath. All secondary stats are almost the same at the moment at decent ilevels. So Breath will win (as stated before) because of the bigger intellect proc on it.
I was in a similar predicament, except on top of TF Cha-ye's and N Totem, I also had H Wushoolay's. I switched the Wushoolay's for the Totem and am probably keeping Cha-ye's until Black Blood, assuming I can switch out the totem for the Bindings.