Some of the players move on to other guilds and some of the players quit. I've seen this in every recent guild I've been in -- the moment the guild falls apart, some of those players never log on again.
That's bad for the game.
This might be a surprise for you, but giving the player everything they want isn't good for the game.
- - - Updated - - -
None of this should be difficult to figure out for yourselves if you'd just sit there and actually think about it for a moment.