I tend to follow the BiS list on GuildOx..
Paragon's Hunter's statement seems to be logical.
"The pen is mightier than the sword.. and considerably easier to write with."
More or less this.
1 If you have access to any SOO Weapon. Use it.
2 If you have access to a Garrosh BOA Weapon. Use it.
3 If you have access to a HC Weapon. Use it.
4 If you have access to a HC Garrosh BOA Weapon. Use it.
5 If you have access to a WF HC Weapon. Use it.
7 If you have access to a WF HC Klaxxi Weapon. Use it. (This is BIS 95% of the time)
Some weapons might be a VERY slight upgrade depending on your specc and current ilevel.
But if you here asking what weapon to use i suspect that minor diff does not matter to you.
TLR LEARN TO SIM YOUR CURRENT SPECC TO GET A INSTANT ANSWER ! ! !! !
i was simming my character the other day to look up some offset items i got awhile ago and i got some combinations of gear where mastery wasnt the worst stat and in nearly all of the sims the difference in statweightvalue wasnt as clear cut as i would like to have had it, so i would tend to think warforged > nonwf bcz weapon dmg should allways outweight the mediocre difference in statvalue haste/crit/mastery have?
<Divinity> US-Kel'thuzad 14/14H US 8th 10 man
Recruiting exceptional raiders for 20man mythic content. Click here to apply.
reason why galakras is higher than the xbow is because the damage spread on the weapon. even tho is normalized you still get better results somehow, needs confimation from one of the theoricrafters.
at the end of the day you use what u get, i got the canon and i use it for both, right now im crit->haste->mastery but i think i would get better results by going crit->mastery->haste for bm or even haste->mastery->crit for bm.