Finally raided again with the rogue - Thok, Siegecrafter, Klaxxi and some Garrosh tries - i think next week if we raid enough we can finally tackle him down.
Here is the log.
when i looked though your logs i noticed that your ambush dmg is realy behind, so on thok for example you have 18 ambushes whil you have 5 dances and 4 vanishes ...
Normaly you get 3-4 ambushes from a dance and 2 ambushes from a Vanish... worst case you should have atleast 21 Ambushes in that kill, i cant seem to find your mistake but thats something you should look into.
btw. i found this fix for your logs, http://www.mediafire.com/download/l6...imv/WOLFix.exe just run it through and reexport you will have your melee swings back!
About the WoL issue.
They have solved the problem. They did a retroactiv So you can read the previous, it includes melee attacks.
Upload it to Warcraftlogs Coldkil, it's what I've been toying with since WoL went derpy with melee hits. It works well and is quite easy to use.
Here is my log for the boss,I was tunneling him 24/7 as the dps on jailor was more than enough.
Nice damage last time the other rogue was assigned to add, but he got targeted by thok, i needed to switch, and obviously thok started to think a panda was a suitable snack more than one time
Added yesterday's log to main post and here.
Some wipes due to deconcentration especially on nazgrim which could been easily avoided; our first try at shamans ended mid-fight due to them disappear and reset without no appearent reason XD
EDIT: Malkorok seems a good single-target fight, but it's much "harder" than IJ - more on the level of shamans. A lot of tank and boss movement which leads to constantly run behind the boss to BS; getting in the void zones can result in dps loss (depending on the place they spawn); phases in which you must stay on front of the boss and rely on Hemo. Combat would pull much better numbers here imho - for sure it wouldn't be so messy to play.
For comparative purposes.
I am a semi-raid leader and I find it detracts more when I'm sub than when I'm combat.
I only played sub on Norushen, IJ and Thok.
I have to get in the melee circles on Malkorok so always being behind the boss is a tad hard - also have to stack for blood rage. I perform better as Combat on the fight I think.
For Malkorok you can ask your tank to always turn the boss the same way between breaths. It will be much easier to be behind the boss.
Moreover use the CoS during breath allows you to attack from behind even if you're not in the safe zone.
In Heroic it won't be the same, however. Play sub if you don't have to get the voids.
@coldkill, played sub on shamans hc this week, really challenging to play in midst of all that chaos, but it was great fun to keep the rotation going while keeping track of all the crap that was being thrown at melee. We executed the split boss tac with 3 tank while that reduced difficulty considderably had we done it both of them in same area, but a fun fight nonetheless.
Far from perfect execution , could have got in couple more shadowdances, screwed out of some of dances with tank moving(rather sprinting away) to avoid the crap.
No rank on iron jugg tho, as we use the stand away from boss and twiddle your thumbs tactic for Phase 2 .