Originally Posted by
Raiju
No this was 90% decided by the tactic used. Midwinter actually did a smoother and faster sha kill, but because they risked the insane 2 tank tactic on dark shamans instead of just playing safe 3 tank like method, they lost. Both guilds oneshot malkorok and siegecrafter right after, following method wiping 3 times? on garrosh to midwinter only getting one attempt in.
If midwinter had gone 3 tank dark shaman, both would have hit garrosh at similar times most likely and it would have been anyones call given both wiped it.