The last time I felt REALLY special was back in vanilla, when I was the second (first on Horde side) to obtain Benediction/Anathema.
Back then our server was heavily Alliance-sided which meant that we, as Horde, barely had a chance to kill Kazzak for the Eye of Shadow(?).
I then found out via Thottbot (those were the days ^^) that the Eye also dropped off the demons in Winterspring but with a crazy low rate. I managed to solo them by kiting them with SWP around the little ruin a bit down the road. Took like 6 minutes for a single demon to kill, but it worked. After dozens of demons I finally got the Eye.
I even made a guide for it and got a few props for it.
oh, there it is, still alive: http://wow.ingame.de/forum/sanctifie...rspring-75605/
(German, sorry :>)