I got bored one day and was toying around with a sub spec, throwing it into SC when I noticed that by the ShC sim my numbers for sub should be considerably higher then my numbers as sin (25k or so increase when i checked in my current gear). So I went and spent a couple weeks practicing with sub, to the point where I was able to pull bout 200k on a dummy unbuffed (a feat i cant manage as sin) so I decided to give it a go lastnight in our siege run... lets just say it did not end as well as i had hoped.
Two things to take into account when looking at these logs, i have been playing sin for years now even in ds when it was considered trash i still excelled with it, I am by no means the best at it but its safe to say im up there and sub i have only two weeks practice with which alone may be the issue. Secondly im also the raid leader, a miserable thing to be when melee lol so while attempting not to fail at sub i also have to be calling things out, watching timers, and trying to keep an eye on the raid while attempting to do a more complex rotation with sub. That being said im sure I made mistakes, and id love some advice from those who know it far better then I.
Logs for sub: http://worldoflogs.com/reports/rt-bp...?s=5148&e=5477
Logs for sin: http://worldoflogs.com/reports/rt-bp...?s=8964&e=9357
I used sha of pride and iron jug as the examples because they both require minimal movement on my part, and minimal focus on the raid so they are the two best that i can focus in on my dps, as you can tell the difference in numbers is significant. Its worth noting that in both cases im reforged as SC said to for sub, since all priorities seem viable for sin with the 2 set.
Thanks for the help folks,
GM of The Band of the Red Hand