I am all for clearcut rules. My point is that these rules can be taken down
after someone has beat a Gym Leader and challenges him again to possible enter the E4.
What I am thinking is like that:
The 1st you challenge and until you beat a specific Gym Leader, both players will be bound by standard rules. When/If the challenger beats the Gym Leader for one time, the Leader will then recognise the Challenger's right to aqcuire a badge from him and the challenger can earn it by beating him again with switching allowed for the Leader and any other rule they deem needs to be changed.
When/If the challenger beats the leader for the 2nd time, then the leader is oblige to provide a badge by posting here and providing the code of the replay. When/If someone has all badges they can enter the E4 where they will find 4 gym leaders with a full team of 6 and only standard smogon rules applied.
If they beat them as well, then they can challenge the Champion who will be another Gym Leader with again a full team of 6 and Smogon rules. If they do, they are awarded the title of the Champion. What they will do with that, we can discuss, but it's far far far away for now