I started with Card Captor, then Tenchi, then Love Hina. After that I started hanging out at Borders and reading manga. Usually I'll introduce my gamer friends into anime with SAO and if they like it I usually have them watch the Fate/Kaleids and Paprika. I know those are a sharp turn from SAO but the friends I have done this with all talk about anime more than video games with me now, which suits me just fine.