Holy shit, that guy is 10/10M and I'm stuck here at 10/10HC
Life is hard :\
The real reason is that tanking is a pisstake at this point and you can carry unbelievable amounts of idiocy with even half-decent healers.
That, and the average guild recruiter has no fucking clue how to read a log, never mind what in particular to look for with each tank. The majority of recruitment officers are absolutely heinously incompetent until you get into the top 50-75 worldwide.
I'd probably second this. Usually as DPS you just look at the meters. For healers it's a bit similar. For both roles you have more players in the guild that can give their opinions. For tanks you usually only have 1, maybe 2 people that actually know how to play tank and not necessarily the class which the guy is on.
So really, you can't tell just from DPS/HPS meters which means most people don't know where to go.
Last edited by mmocffdec12f27; 2015-06-06 at 11:15 PM.
And yet the easiest class to get carried - even in wake of what tanking is - is hunter.
It's shocking the absolute shit you see even in top 100 guilds - from ALL roles. Tanking isn't really an outlier, you have just as many shit disc priests, holy paladins, fotm dps specs, etc. who get carried by fotm-ness and barely perform enough on fights to pass trials (or don't pass and just keep hopping up)
You can't really keep that up though. If you are a shit dps getting shit dps rankings, you get kicked.
If you are a tank getting shit dps rankings, and I see plenty of them around, they just shrug their shoulders and say 'muh job ain't to dps, its to survive'. As if its solely their achievement they did, and not the healers who carried them. I'm not sure who said it on some tank thread here, but really the best measure of a tanks performance, and there aren't many, is DPS; it just at least lets you know they aren't a retard.
With the caveat that it's the best metric by which you can quickly judge a tank's performance. DPS isn't the end-all (doing high DPS on Thogar and Beastlord need not be indicative of your skill as a tank) - it takes a thorough analysis to determine how a tank performs in other regards which is what nightfalls and PraisetheSun were referring to I imagine.
Of course, a quick look through a tanks logs and if its all 30s and 40s percentiles, you probably have some issues.
Then you ought to investigate it, delve further. Look at the guy being discussed, his immediate damage logs indicate a problem, and on examining there appears to be one.
I tend to spam deathstrike as its the only real spamable ability. While i wait to spread more diseases/gather aggro etc. Blood dk is missing something like that. I know that is wrong to do so, but i only ever arse about lfr anyways, great guide very helpful even for an alt
Many thanks for checking logs <3
To touch more about tanks logs, I find tanks to be one of the hardest logs to properly read. While it's still always highly useful, and can obvisouly help with gameplay issues, there's more to tanking than being able to press buttons in the correct order. Yes it's mandatory, and yes it's kinda sad to see players having so much issues with their basic rotation, but even then, there's a bit more than that to tanking.
Position boss/mobs properly, picking up shit, being able to call for an external and/or ask for healer's attention when needed are all things you can't really see watching logs.
I'd kinda disagree with Solaire, as in, sure tanking in itself isn't that hard, any fucker can do it and get carried by healers, but there really is a lot you can do to ease the life of everyone in your raid, and actually help progression. While we sure have less of an impact than in MoP (vengeance pls, come back), the difference between someone afk tanking and someone who will actually deal with annoying mechanics is huge. Same can be said for others roles ofc, but looking at BRF, there was plenty of fights were if both your tanks were fuckers, you would have an awful time (ie Gruul, Oregorger, Furnace, Maidens' boat, Blackhand, Kromog, etc).
Last edited by Piwielle; 2015-06-07 at 04:55 AM.
People who are playing their class right as a tank typically do decent dps anyway. If a pally is doing 15k DPS in mythic and just shrugs his shoulders and goes "not muh job to DPS" you can fucking guarentee his SoTR uptime is probably lower than someone with 25-30k with equal talents.
Regarding the AMS change:
Everyone here says that AMS's absorption no longer scales with Resolve, but the wording makes it seem that the damage absorbed by the ability no longer affects the computation of Resolve. Is this just poor wording?However, damage absorbed no longer causes Resolve.
It still scales with Resolve on PTR last I checked. This actually is just literally what it says, meaning I don't know why the hell they bothered to change it because it doesn't make any sense at all.
Probably going do some 6.2 stuff soon. Honestly it's really stupid and it doesn't really matter what you do is the summary, but as usual Blizzard managed to make some real stinker trinkets, even ones that were intended to be good.
I write guides and have a youtube channel where I make kill videos at: https://www.youtube.com/user/EssEmmI
Feel free to ask me for help regarding to Blood DK play
We need a pretty light show trinket trox that thing is so good!
I write guides and have a youtube channel where I make kill videos at: https://www.youtube.com/user/EssEmmI
Feel free to ask me for help regarding to Blood DK play
So, are they going to increase our damage outside of BoS? Or just remove it and lol. I feel like from testing so far, tank damage is horrid. What ever happened to 75% of a dps players output as the goal?