She just gave me an update on the situation.
Because she's on disability and receiving medicare she has to pay personal protection insurance, which is medical coverage for hospitalization incase of an accident and the ambulance ride, because medicare won't cover that. That part of her policy is $2100/year through All-State, if it weren't for that her premium would $800/year.
So right now her total is $2900/year. Apparently when she turns 60 she can decline to have this (from what I read, could be wrong), but that's not for another 8 years.
I guess what she's saying is that because she doesn't have medical insurance outside of Medicare, she has to have this extra shit. With that, she can't opt out of any of it. She has to put into it for things that are useless to her like wage loss.