Terrible Luck and Weapon Choice

[floatinginthesea]

To start, I have the absolute worst luck when it comes to rolling on weapons. The best that I had been able to get at this point was a Heroic (630) Tharbek's Brutal Posessor. I was running a PUG Highmaul Heroic hoping to get the Butcher's Bloody Cleaver (It didn't happen) but a Heroic (670) The Bladefist did drop off of Kargath, and there was no one that could use it so I kept it.

I ran a sim with both weapons thru SC and it spit out that The Bladefist was a better choice. The question: Is The Bladefist better with its 40 ilvl difference even though I lose 72 Strength, or did I set something wrong in SC and I should still run with the strength weapon, even if it is that much lower. If I could get a 655 or 670 Strength weapon I would obviously switch ... but with RNG being RNG I don't know when I will have that chance.

Thoughts?

(The rest of my gear can be found on Aorta - Twisting Nether - US)

[Deleted]

I'm running with 2x Butchers cleaver(1x670, 1x661), and its been awsome since then. So just save your bonus rolls butcher and try to get in a progressing guild that can clear hm norm and has some progress in hc. PUGs can sometime be nice but more often than not its just a mess.
Oh and btw, dont take the bladefist, the str loss is not worth it.

[Crisius]

Simcraft isn't lying, weapon damage is worth much more than the loss of strength. You should use the bladefist 'til you get a strength weapon of similar itemlevel.