2 Warrior DD or 2 Ret Mythic Raiding BRF

[Ferali]

What would be the best to include on a mythic BRF raiding guild an extra Warrior DD or Ret?

[Deleted]

Most importantly: The better player.

If the player is the same: I would go for Warrior.

[Ferali]

Is the same player . Class preference is not a problem for the player.

Info that can help decision:

Guild has:
1 Prot Warrior
1 Prot Paladin
1 Holy Pala

[Wunderland]

I'm biased, as I play Ret and I'm not very familiar with warriors in WoD, but if loot and player ability isn't in question, go Ret! Passive and active damage mitigation for a lot of the spell-based AoE helps a lot, they bring tank CDs, and are bursty single target or cleave if specced for it to get you through some of the encounters where that's necessary. Movement isn't as good as a Warrior has, but there are ways to work around that as well.

[aznxk3vi17]

One each, Pally CDs too stronk

[Temp name]

I'd rather an extra paladin, but my guild doesn't really need the damage.

Paladin CD's are just better than warrior ones (HoSac + HoP > Rallying).

[Roiids]

AOE fights a warrior that plays right will blow the doors off ret. But Pallys have cheese abilities where as warriors have none.

[Deemerbob]

I'd rather an extra paladin, but my guild doesn't really need the damage.

Paladin CD's are just better than warrior ones (HoSac + HoP > Rallying).

Warriors also have vigilance