Originally Posted by
Killedbydeath
Sure i have. And while i get what you mean, it's a whole other matter to have the support of the original company that produces the game, than a private server. In fact people avoid private servers because many things (some p2w, not bug-free content, scripting not even close to the original , just to name some).
If Bliz recreates Vanilla/TBC/WoTLK servers , they will have a hype... Major factor is the unique things any class had to offer and the game totally lacks now. Nowdays the game revolves around one or maybe two factors. One of them is a number (damage/heal/dps call it as you like) and the other one is CC (if you count PvP as well). Back there you had to think from buffs to mana efficiency , damage /heals , CC and a shitload of other stuff that actually made the game WAR-CRAFT... it was an art.
Anyway... if you count how many people play Privates with bugs and stuff only to play "TBC" or "Vanilla"...an idea of those, You can have a full battlegroup ( i think) and while in a private people come and go (because of mad stuff may happening) , in the real deal they will stay.
From my RL friends i can count at least 10-15 people they would go full time TBC or Wotlk or even Vanilla. While from them we play WoW 2-3 people now and all of us have big breaks here and there.
Any way you can see it the truth is 1. They will make even more money if they actually could release older expansions. They know it, they just don't want to admit it...