Originally Posted by
Xar226
I don't know how it works in high school softball, but in Major League Baseball the catcher is not allowed to block the plate unless he has the ball in his hands.
Further, saying the runner was "coming straight at her" isn't fair. See the white line at the bottom of the image? That's the basepath. The catcher is completely obliterating the runner's path to home plate, so much so that the runner is actually coming around from the side. That's an active attempt to avoid her, while still running hard and making the necessary step on the plate.
Could she have gone even farther out of the basepath and tried to sidestep a toe onto the furthest back of the plate to completely avoid the catcher? Possibly. The possibility doesn't justify escalating a situation that you caused yourself, though.
More importantly, if you look at the second time you see that there wasn't even that option. She completely blocks the plate with her leg, shuffles off and then elbows the runner. Big pile of nope.