trinket question (ret)

[leeroys]

I picked up Forgemaster's Insignia (Heroic). Currently have Vial of Convulsive Shadows (normal) and Horn of Screaming Spirits (normal).

As ret paladin, which two should I choose?

[RagnorZ]

Vial and Forgemaster's

Generally you always want 1 on use and 1 proc/passive trinket and H Forge edges out the N Horn because of the huge strength difference, even tho the mastery proc on Horn is better than Forge's proc for us.

[Phyrra]

As far as I know, Forgemasters is pretty mediocre compared to your other options in the same tier. Since it's a tier higher though, go with it and vial. If at any point you get a heroic horn of screaming spirits, I would replace forgemasters.