There are also Muslims in The US and I would be less afraid. It not being afraid of Muslims - its more being afraid of what the Muslim population allows itself to act upon.
In Israel muslims won't pick on you or harass you, yes they might try to kill you in a terror attack but those usually end VERY fast with a dead terrorist because a. Tons of armed military and police forces on street (both active and on vacation) and b. When attack starts a lot of Israelies are actually try to get to the terrorist and neutralize him instead of running for their life (a lot people have military experience). I think there were over 1000 terror attacks in last months, and like ~20-30 israeli dead and ~150-200 terrorist dead. In Europe you could expect to ~3000-10000 civilian deaths if it would happen there.
Harassment are dealt with harshly and not like in Sweden and rest of Europe where it is silenced if its done by Muslims. (harassment of all side, not just jews). So yes even with all the terror attacks I feel much safer in Israel and all the jews pouring in to Israel from Europe (where its much easier economically) is another indication like Notter said.
EDIT:
My bad :P - fixed!