Originally Posted by
Spikeyshadow
CH is not worth the effort in my opinion. From my heroic clear this week it never did more than 1.64% and it was often below 1. You can check your own damage under UA.
Do neither of you have the 4 set? I'm drowning in shards most of the time though to be fair I am currently on 19% haste, have Whispers and I have the belt as well but I am lucky if the latter gives me 3 shards on a fight. There is no stopping to wait for buffs, it's dump or cap, dump or cap. In an ideal world sure I would wait but in practice it is not possible personally so I focus more on making sure I fully drain them all. What I do try to do though is sync as many buffs as I can together and then use Reap so they are still worth tracking.
Whispers is a special case. Different people have different ideas on it and I am in the camp of drain rather than spamming UAs, though not capping, during the procs just something to bear in mind.
Add any racial, Reap, certain other trinket procs, Soul Harvest if you will use it and potions to your buff list.
- - - Updated - - -
Oh and don't pay too much attention to the number Drain soul Casts (or believe that the same item level will do the same DPS) as some people spam and some not. What you do want to look at is Drain Soul uptime.
For comparison look more to fight length than worry about item level in my opinion. You want to compare yourself to the best logs.
Yes you wasted 3 Shards. Resources>Soul Shards.