I'm looking for a hybrid melee class to heal and DPS with. I've leveled both up to 102 to get a decent feel for how both play and I've enjoyed both. Which class post-tuning is currently performing better in mythics/raids in healing and DPS? As a group leader, which would you take given the same exact item level?
For last nights warcraft logs:
For stright up DPS; Enhance, then Ret, then Ele. Enhance may be the strongest single target class right now, if not it's very close.
For pure HPS; Holy P, then Resto S. Both were very close.
It looks like (based on one single night's logs of 3-7k parses) that both are doing strong in heroic.
If I was putting together a raid I'd take both. If I was putting together a mythic+ dungeon I would only take guild members and probably who know who is better. I don't see one class being superior to the other at this time. I do main a Ret paladin, this may make me more likely to take another place class for the loot sharing.