Originally Posted by
Rucati
Er, if I remove my waist I drop from 868 to 811, which would be about a 6% difference, which is about twice as much. Close though I guess?
Regardless, I'm fairly certain we wouldn't drop very much at all. The difference isn't nearly as big as people seem to think, unless everyone just forgot previous expansions. Reckful got rank 1 back in MoP on a Rogue in blues/greens, which would be about a 50% decrease, or when he did it with weapons equipped from a previous expansion (forget when that was, maybe Wrath?). Or that Hunter whose name I forget that got 1900 in 2s in Burning Crusade wearing nothing but ring/trinket/neck/weapon.
Skill is significantly more important than gear, and it always has been. The difference is that in the past gear was a much much bigger factor, like upwards of 70%. Now gear is at max like 10%, which while still relevant isn't nearly as insurmountable.
Plus the whole point of this thread was casual PvP, where gear is pretty irrelevant because if you're playing for fun 3% is meaningless.