Maxweii, I enjoy reading your posts and appreciate your work, but I'm not understanding why you said "informed DK's most do choose BRW". According to the Mythic Logs provided at WarcraftLogs, sorted by All Bosses -> Mythic -> Unholy DK's, there are only 3 instances where a DK in the Top 10 DPS on any boss, actually took BRW:
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/ranking...ht&spec=Unholy
- Once on Harjatan (Rank 1 parse)
- Once on Mistress Sassz'ine (Rank 4 parse)
- Once on Sisters of the Moon (Rank 8 parse).
So clearly, as you said, the talent is very viable, but I don't see any sort of majority of DK's taking BRW, as you suggested (I am paraphrasing a bit). Furthermore, if we peek into the logs of just Mythic Goroth, we find out that BRW is only taken 5 times out of the first 100 parses:
https://www.warcraftlogs.com/ranking...holy&boss=2032
Now, I will say that I haven't gone through all of the those pages of logs (on Mythic Goroth or any of the other bosses, but I'm willing to venture a strong bet here that it is mostly the same) to actually check at what percentage of players haven taken BRW over PP on any given fight, but to me, it seems that
MOST players prefer to use PP over BRW. Actually, I just checked, and I only saw 22 DKs taking BRW in the Top 400 logs on Mythic Goroth, or a 5.5% usage rate.
I don't want to have an argument over the talents, as I respect your work very much, but it looks to me the opposite of what you said, and more in line with what Hyper said earlier:
What am I missing here?
Cheers