Page 2 of 168 FirstFirst
1
2
3
4
12
52
102
... LastLast
  1. #21

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by frozenpatato
    Dumb because he cannot rate properly.

    What is crappy in the armory you quoted?
    If I had to guess it's because someone said that they should have desecration when in fact desecration blows. It's not worth the talent points.

    Now... back on track.

  2. #22

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by frozenpatato
    Dumb because he cannot rate properly.

    What is crappy in the armory you quoted?
    The only thing terribly wrong with that armory is a near total lack of enchants.

    That's really bad.

  3. #23

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Offhand
    The only thing terribly wrong with that armory is a near total lack of enchants.

    That's really bad.
    Also:
    Low hit rating. Low expertise.

  4. #24

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Let's not go off-topic now guys,
    Quote Originally Posted by ImmÒrtality
    Pretty nice, though, I don't know why you don't have any in desecration. 8.5/10

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...m%C3%B4rtality

    is mine!
    6/10, decent gear - I'd go blood for raid dps.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...s&n=Illmarilol - Some JC stuff that ain't updated yet. (Trinket and prismatic gems.)

    Gotta have more Goatbell.

  5. #25
    Mechagnome frozenpatato's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Québec (Canada)
    Posts
    626

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Offhand
    The only thing terribly wrong with that armory is a near total lack of enchants.

    That's really bad.
    Didn't see that... Couldn't open it again since "Server is busy" once again for armory.

    Can't rate, at school and the proxy block all WoW links lol

  6. #26

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Illmar
    Let's not go off-topic now guys,
    6/10, decent gear - I'd go blood for raid dps.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...s&n=Illmarilol - Some JC stuff that ain't updated yet. (Trinket and prismatic gems.)
    9/10

    Solid Gear, Def Caped and have good avoidence. The only reason I didn't give you a 10/10 is because you took descration, which is really more of an opinion thing than a proved good or bad talent.

    Be gentle with me I recently hit 80 and have had NO luck with drop rates and have been saving gold for my elite flyer rather than getting enchants and stuff. Also I just respeced for dual wield dps to test it out, so I guess rate the spec more than the gear.
    Yes I know one of blades is a tanking blade, I couldn't find a decent blue sword or axe on the AH in the 3 hours since I respeced.

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&n=Parkerposie

  7. #27

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by AsIlaydying
    9/10

    Solid Gear, Def Caped and have good avoidence. The only reason I didn't give you a 10/10 is because you took descration, which is really more of an opinion thing than a proved good or bad talent.

    Be gentle with me I recently hit 80 and have had NO luck with drop rates and have been saving gold for my elite flyer rather than getting enchants and stuff. Also I just respeced for dual wield dps to test it out, so I guess rate the spec more than the gear.
    Yes I know one of blades is a tanking blade, I couldn't find a decent blue sword or axe on the AH in the 3 hours since I respeced.

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&n=Parkerposie
    6/10

    Spec is the fabled cookie cutter spec I presume. Gave you a 6 since clearly you only dinged 80 recently and haven't had chance to improve much on your gear yet. But you are a brave man, starting out with the tri-spec thingy instead of just wielding a big hitting 2 hander and going for easy unholy insane dps=> that earned you some points

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...nd&n=Shinukage

  8. #28

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Gwydi0n
    6/10

    Spec is the fabled cookie cutter spec I presume. Gave you a 6 since clearly you only dinged 80 recently and haven't had chance to improve much on your gear yet. But you are a brave man, starting out with the tri-spec thingy instead of just wielding a big hitting 2 hander and going for easy unholy insane dps=> that earned you some points

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...nd&n=Shinukage
    9/10

    Almost got a 10/10 because obviously your gear is good. Nice ap, hit, and exp. I just questioned your talent into gargoyle rather than vampiric blood. Guess this depends more on whether you are a raider or a pvper. Also not a big fan of just puttin 1/3 points or 1/5 points into a talent just so u can get further down the tree.

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...e&n=Unholykush

  9. #29

    Re: Rate the DK above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Gwydi0n
    6/10

    Spec is the fabled cookie cutter spec I presume. Gave you a 6 since clearly you only dinged 80 recently and haven't had chance to improve much on your gear yet. But you are a brave man, starting out with the tri-spec thingy instead of just wielding a big hitting 2 hander and going for easy unholy insane dps=> that earned you some points

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...nd&n=Shinukage
    yeah i am super excited to possibilties with better gear. I am at about 12% miss rate but my dps is around 2100 in five mans : ) Killing machine proc is bread and butter.

  10. #30

    Rate the Death Knight above you.

    I made a post like this on Mage forums, basically it's to consolidate the thread spam where people always want to be individually "rated".

    Typical format for the thread can (but is not limited to):
    -Suggestions/Compliments to the person above you.
    -Armory Link
    -Any problems/concerns you are having/just something you want us to know.

    Helpful things to include is checking enchants, checking hit rating, expertise, talent tree choices.


    I'll start out I guess <gulp>

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...+52&n=Oblivius

    Two weeks since I dinged 80, it's an alt. The second spec is for soloing Old World content. First one has one or two leveling talents, but raids decently.

    Wow it's been a long time since I posted this. Haha.

  11. #31

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Well, I'd say get pve enchants for head and shoulders (and get dps shoulders :P). Also better enchants possible for cloack, wrists and boots (since ur already over hit cap). Crit chance is also a bit low, but I guess you'll do fine anyway.

    About myself, I need to get new enchant on my cloack and some more arp gear would be nice.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...Vashj&n=Akafin

  12. #32

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Pretty good overall, but. Keep in mind that +16 str gems almost always is better than going with 8 str/12 stam etc just for the socket bonus. Also, shoulders wtf:P? I think I could find about 10 better blue for a dps tbh.

    And the spec, it's almost perfect, but change Rune Tap to Mark of Blood, and take the points out of Morbidity and put them in Ravenous Dead and Runic Power Master OR Night of the Dead. I'd go with Night of the Dead myself. The Glyphs look fine and you shouldn't change anything there. Theres a couple of enchants able to get improvements aswell

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ether&n=Moriko gogo^^ Keep in mind I got to 80 tuesday last week =p Also, I got the BoH tank trinket instead of the one from MGT - hc.
    Sig courtesy the awesome zomgname~

  13. #33

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Again pretty decent gear to start with, not entirely clued up on frost tanking but the spec looks ok. Id look into getting a hodir shoulder enchant and some argent rep for a head enchant for some more +def.

    All id say is getting to 540 defense is something ya would need to look at, would make your healers happy atleast

    This is my armory link. Note i dont have the exp soft cap yet and still have T7.5 shoulders. Iv been really unlucky with stupid drops for those slots. Armory doesnt show Arp still but i have in my dps gear 466 rating which works out at 47.34% including talents.

    My off spec blood tanking build is mostly for just soloing old world stuff for shits and giggles and for if im every needed to tank in 25 mans. Have some half decent tanking gear to go with it.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...4%C3%ACy%C3%A0

    EDIT- yes i know im technically 1% over the hit cap, there isnt anything i can do about that except change my race

  14. #34

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Quote Originally Posted by Haibara
    And the spec, it's almost perfect, but change Rune Tap to Mark of Blood, and take the points out of Morbidity and put them in Ravenous Dead and Runic Power Master OR Night of the Dead. I'd go with Night of the Dead myself.
    I'd actually go for 1 in imp blood presence since Mark of Blood is useless in raids. Also the increased damage of DC is pretty good and I personally would just max out Ravenous dead and leave the rest in Morbidity

    @ Venjer

    I actually have nothing to say. Gems and enchants are all perfect. And as far as I know str > expertise, at least untill ~6k ap raidbuff, but ye. Really good dk imho.

  15. #35

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    - Be def capped as soon as possible.
    - Enchant your cloak
    - Enchant your helm
    - Enchant your bracer
    About your Frost spec:
    - Get improved Icy touch instead of Runic Power mastery
    - Lichborne is not very usefull for a tank
    About your blood spec :
    - Spell deflection is not very usefull
    - Get epidemic
    - Use Glyph of runic strike instead or Dark death.

    - Rename your character (just kidding)
    - Aim for 7% hit not 8, you are a draneï


    My toon:
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...nels&n=Kahorie

  16. #36
    trainwreck
    Guest

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Quote Originally Posted by Korigan
    6/10 It looks like you want to tank but don't really know what you are doing using something like Worldcarver and a dodge rating sigil. Try getting rid of the blue trinket to it brings down your level so bosses will hit you harder.

    Mine: http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...e&n=Frostmorne

  17. #37

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    I dunno if this is for PvE or PvP, but in either case you could use severe upgrades.

    3/10 (-1 for what you said about the DK above you, the iLvL has nothing to do with boss strength against you)

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...m&n=Lovepotato

  18. #38

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Nothing to say except you have to farm Son of Hodir reputation and to enchant your cloak.

    Quote Originally Posted by trainwreck
    6/10 It looks like you want to tank but don't really know what you are doing using something like Worldcarver and a dodge rating sigil. Try getting rid of the blue trinket to it brings down your level so bosses will hit you harder.
    Well, my goal is to tank hard hitting boss by maximizing Effective Health, like Steelbreaker or Vezax without omitting threat stats. So I try to stay close to Expertise cap and hit cap without sacrifice anything. That is where Worldcarver is for.
    About the blue trinket, before the 2 stamina trinket in Ulduar, I don't see better trinket, the 1 minute cooldown is perfect coupled with IBF.
    And for the dodge sigil, if you see a better tanking sigil let me know.

  19. #39

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Quote Originally Posted by Batsmuggler
    I dunno if this is for PvE or PvP, but in either case you could use severe upgrades.

    3/10 (-1 for what you said about the DK above you, the iLvL has nothing to do with boss strength against you)

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...m&n=Lovepotato
    Get enahcnt for your back, why the hell all gems for Arp ?

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...Nerub&n=Niltag

  20. #40

    Re: Rate the Death Knight above you.

    Quote Originally Posted by Niltag
    Get enahcnt for your back, why the hell all gems for Arp ?

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...Nerub&n=Niltag
    Check out the ElitestJerks website, it's quite helpful for both tanking and DPS.

    As for my enchant, that is indeed something I should get but I cannot be assed, I will enchant for sure when Razorscale's cloak drops though.

    (I won't rate this guy, as I've done one already)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •